VanEllin - Cookies, Focaccias & Pretzels

First Stop Fishpaws

First Stop Fishpaws - Main image
$16.5 $33 In stock

Category: Cookie

Inspired by our favorite liquor market, Fishpaws, this cookie takes the ubiquitous chocolate chip cookie to a next level. Infused with bourbon and chocolate, this crispy cookie is classic comfort with grown-up depth. 

Customer Reviews (4.8 / 5 · 5 reviews)

Harper ★★★★★

The bourbon flavor is subtle but definitely there, giving the chocolate chips a warm, almost boozy depth that I didn’t expect from a cookie. It’s crispy all the way through, which makes it perfect for dunking in coffee without falling apart. I’ve already eaten three.

Julian ★★★★★

The edges are perfectly crispy while the middle stays chewy, and that bourbon warmth lingers just enough after each bite. I've already finished half the bag in one sitting, they're dangerously good.

Olivia Y. ★★★★★

That bourbon kick is subtle but unmistakable, and it pairs perfectly with the crisp edges. The chocolate is dark and rich, so it doesn’t feel like a gimmick—just a really good twist on a classic. I finished the whole bag in two sittings.